Knee Replacement May Be a Lifesaver for Some
By TARA PARKER-POPEBy the time 64-year-old Laura Milson decided to undergo total knee replacement after 12 years of suffering from arthritis, even a short walk to the office printer was a struggle.
After her surgery last August at the Rothman Institute at Thomas Jefferson University in Philadelphia, Ms. Milson spent a week in rehabilitation and says she hasn’t stopped walking since. “My son says to me, ‘You have to slow down,’ and I say, ‘No, I have to catch up!,’ ” she said. “It’s a whole different life.”
For Ms. Milson, who lives in Shrewsbury, Pa., replacing the joint in her right knee came with a surprising bonus: a 20-pound weight loss in two months. “I joked with my doctor, ‘I think you put a diet chip in my knee,’ ” she said. “The weight just sort of came off.”
Now she has joined Weight Watchers to drop a few extra pounds and is training for a three-day breast cancer walk in October.
For years surgeons have boasted of the pain relief and improved quality of life that often follow knee replacement. But now new research suggests that for some patients, knee replacement surgery can actually save their lives.
In a sweeping study of Medicare records, researchers from Philadelphia and Menlo Park, Calif., examined the effects of joint replacement among nearly 135,000 patients with new diagnoses of osteoarthritis of the knee from 1997 to 2009. About 54,000 opted for knee replacement; 81,000 did not.
Three years after diagnosis, the knee replacement patients had an 11 percent lower risk of heart failure. And after seven years, their risk of dying for any reason was 50 percent lower.
The study, presented this month at the annual meeting of the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons, was financed with a grant from a knee replacement manufacturer. It was not randomized, so it may be that these patients were healthier and more active to start with.
Still, the researchers did try to control for differences in age and overall health. And the findings are consistent with large studies of knee replacement and mortality in Scandinavia. Given the big numbers in the study and the size of the effect, the data strongly suggest that knee replacement may lead to improvements in health and longevity.
The theory behind knee replacement, said the study’s lead author, Scott Lovald, senior associate at Exponent, a scientific consulting firm in Menlo Park, is that it improves quality of life. “At the end of the day, we’re trying to figure out if quantity of life increases as well,” he added, noting that the team was conducting a similar review of Medicare data on the long-term benefits of hip replacement surgery.
The founder of the Rothman Institute, Dr. Richard H. Rothman, who has performed 25,000 joint replacement surgeries in his career, urged caution in interpreting data that are not randomized and controlled. Not every patient with knee arthritis is a candidate for joint replacement surgery, he said.
“People can tolerate a lot of knee disability for reasons we don’t totally understand,” he went on, adding, “If the pain is acceptable, you live with it; if it’s not acceptable, we’ll operate on you.”
Dr. Rothman said that whether patients experience better health after surgery depends on motivation — how motivated they were to stay fit before surgery and how motivated they are now to become more active.
“For the motivated patient, it allows them to walk through that portal and become better conditioned and lose weight,” he said. “It’s not a weight-reduction program. It’s a potential avenue to improve your level of fitness, weight, cardiovascular health and mental health.”
Edward Moore, a 94-year-old retired chemist in Woodbury, N.J., underwent knee replacement three years ago after pain began limiting his activity. Given his age, his own daughter had worried that the recovery would be too difficult. But Dr. Rothman agreed he was healthy enough for the procedure.
“I didn’t do much mulling about it,” Mr. Moore said. “It just seemed like the knee would be hampering me for the rest of my life, and that sounded like a bad idea.”
Mr. Moore said he had an uneventful recovery, and in September, two days after his 94th birthday, he took his wind surfer to Lakes Bay near Atlantic City. “I got up on the board, and I sailed,” he said.
William Mills, 63, of Philadelphia, had been suffering for about four years with severe pain in both knees when he opted for double knee replacement in 2006. He said his activity had dropped off, and while he could still play golf, he could no longer walk the course. Even going to a restaurant had become a burden if he couldn’t find a parking space nearby.
“I think one of the things people don’t understand about knees is how bad it is,” said Mr. Mills, a bank executive. “It changes everything. I couldn’t walk two city blocks. It was just slowly but surely changing my life where I was unable to really enjoy things.”
But while the rehabilitation of both knees was “the hardest thing I’ve ever done in my life,” he has no regrets. Six months after surgery he took part in a 250-mile bike ride in Germany. He has made a few compromises — he no longer skis, and plays doubles tennis instead of singles — but he says he now rarely thinks about his knees.
“Before surgery, I felt like I was 10 or 15 years older than I was,” he said. “Now I probably feel like I’m 10 or 15 years younger than I am.
“I can understand why people might live longer, because you want to. You really feel good again.”
45 Comments
These true believers are quick to dismiss injuries - anybody who hurts themselves following their guru's instructions must have been misunderstanding or doing it wrong - there is no possibility that the instructor was simply following a pre-scientific prescription which might not have been suitable for the situation.
Folks, yoga (like tai chi) is a form of exercise. It's not magic. It does not "purge toxins" any more than comparable physical activity. Its instructors are not mystically enlightened, and more importantly, are not doctors. Nobody has ever been able to conclusively demonstrate the existence of "prana" or "qi" or "bio-energy" - and for anyone who can, there is a sweet $1M prize available from of jref.org !
Exercise can certainly have positive effects, and coming up with systems that make the exercise more interesting, offer low-impact training for the elderly or infirm, or provide for cultural studies is great - I practice Asian martial arts because it's far more fun than simply doing cardio. I'm not suggesting yoga is *bad*. But this is the 21st century, can't we dispense with the pseudo-scientific baggage already?
Om :)
It has taken us hundred of years to finally make yoga mainstream and I hope that its counterpart - ayurveda, makes its way to our lives sooner rather than later. An ancient indian health system, ayurveda is an amazing supplement to yog and our health by assessing our bodies make, type, and problem and integrating the roots of nutrition into our every day. Through change in diet, herbs and balance (yoga and meditation) we begin to renew ourselves on a cellular level.
Unfortunately, the drug companies would never touch this because it isn't synthetic.. That's an oxymoron if i've ever seen one.
-Brian
http://www.progressivetransformation.blogspot.com
If you (or anyone else) can demonstrate these claims of "cellular renewal" or "toxin cleansing" in an objective manner, I suggest they apply immediately for the JREF $1M prize. If these are real effects, winning the prize would be incredibly easy.
http://www.randi.org/site/index.php/1m-challenge.html
Is postural yoga really centuries old? If you think so take a look at http://www.openthemagazine.com/article/living/not-as-old-as-you-think and http://www.amazon.com/Yoga-Body-Origins-Posture-Practice/dp/0195395344/r...
They assert that postural yoga is a very recent development and that the only physical aspect of the centuries old yoga was breath control.
Which is that lying and thinking (imagining) you are doing a pose, is just as good as really doing it. _just as good_.
All the analysis of specifics means not as much as that simple truism which students should always always keep in mind.
However, not all yoga teachers may be methodical enough to do a complete study of the student's status of health. A national accreditation agency may go someway in standardizing yoga therapy, but not enough to avoid avoid injury, I am afraid.
Even if you are not in doubt as to what might suit you best, it is good to go slow, one posture at a time. If yoga is so good that it helps cure disease, then the wrong use of it can just as well have serious undesirable consequences.
So, do your due diligence: search, read, ask and try...and I'm positive you'll find the perfect one for you!
Mike
www.theironyou.com
I have never met a yoga person (and there are millions of them here in Southern California) or an Apple person who admits the shortcomings of their product. This lack of objectivity is suspect; I would be more open to trying something if I was given a rational list of the pros and cons, rather than a overly exuberant one-sided gush fest of platitudes.
What most people dont realize is that stress is the biggest issue that causes health problems because we are not getting breathe deep into our lungs. We are so stressed out that most people do "short breathing" so oxygen is not getting into our blood cells. Ever hear of a "runners high"? Thats because they are high on oxygen!
How truly wonderful that your respect for your colleague helped to open your eyes to yoga. I hope that your journey brings joy, good health, gratification. And relief from suffering.
Nonetheless, I am almost speechless with incredulity and astonishment to read that you were formerly"loathe"to know about yoga. It is almost a topic of discussion, possibly worthy of a memoir in itself.how an editor on the desk of PERSONAL HEALTH for no less an institution than the NY TIMES, somehow managed to be oblivious to one of the biggest PERSONAL HEALTH TRENDS of the past decade.
With ask due respect: that is a fascinating disconnect.
Among the many great pleasures, and challenges, of yoga, is to observe how many people begin their practice of yoga with mostly physical and secular conceptiona, such as you enumerate. But yoga is far more than just the body. I genuinely hope that you stay with your practice long enough to begin to access, and appreciate, those other rewards. I sense that patient practice may help you understand better why you had a"blind spot"to yoga for so many years, and reveal other things you did not see before.
Enjoy the ride.
I look extremely forward to reading future columns and hearing how you evolve. I hope and trust that all of us will be better for it.
You write:
"The Yoga Alliance, a national organization for yoga in the United States, fills in this gap with specific training standards that, if met, earn the title registered yoga teacher. The standards involve either 200 or 500 hours of instruction and supervised practice, with specialized training for children’s and prenatal yoga."
And I would respectfully point out that you are incorrect about that statement.
Yoga alliance has only recently changed their legal status, but more importantly, John Matthews, Lynn Bushnell, Gyandev McCord spent $336,325.00 on NOT fighting yoga regulation, but to promote their own greed.
It is Yoga Alliance's intention to inspire fear and complicity surrounding their loose non-legal credentialing.
So before you make statements about credentialing entities of yoga, please do your homework and know the facts.
John Matthews (who resigned after I printed their tax returns), Lynn Bushnell (who works for YogaWorks) and Gyandev McCord (who represents Ananda Yoga) all represent a legal threat to the education standards of yoga.
Yoga Alliance has not acted with integrity, makes all their employees sign non-disclosure agreements, and really has not added anything to yoga education that wasn't there in the first place.
Brian Castellani
Yoganomics.net
As an off and on practitioner (now off) I know that at the 1st whiff of a competitive atmosphere in a class, run away (before you have to limp away ...) The teacher is key- in experience, understanding of anatomy as well as practice, and attitude.
I think that Kripalu up in the Berkshires does provide excellent introduction for newbies, as well as those with experience.
Then when I talk to physical therapists, they say they see the same in their patients who come because of yoga injuries. The same factors apply to yoga. It was inconceivable when I started out with yoga in the late 1970s that anyone could teach after 200 hours.
It's never too late.
Here is a link to Phoenix Rising Yoga Therapy, a member of the Yoga Alliance. They may be able to assist you in locating a certified yoga therapist in your location.
http://www.pryt.com/directory/directory.html
There are many schools and styles of yoga, each with its own quality or defining characteristic. I have been practicing yoga for 20 years and am a certified teacher through the Kripalu Center for Yoga and Health.
http://www.kripalu.org/
I am in middle age, have hernatied spinal discs (not yoga induced), and am able to lead a functional life with no medication as a result of my yoga practice. Yoga's benefits are holistic. However in my case, yoga asanas (postures) strengthen the lumbar muscles to keep the discs in place, and limit the pinching on the spinal nerves and associated pain.
"Yoga and Stretching Equally Effective for Back Pain"
http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/10/24/yoga-and-stretching-equally-eff...
Yoga breathing (pranayama) can be both energizing and relaxing. There are different types of pranayma depending on the condition or desired outcome in the mind and body. Pranayama is fundamental to the practice of yoga:
A couple of Kripalu-isms:
"If you are not breathing, it's not yoga."
"When the student is ready the teacher will appear."
I anticipate your next article about your salutary explorations and encounters along the yogic path.
Namaste